Top Wedding Caterers in Wisconsin: Delicious Options to Wow Your Guests
Your wedding meal is one of the most memorable parts of the day—right alongside your vows and your first dance. And in Wisconsin, we’re lucky to have a wide variety of talented wedding caterers who can serve up everything from upscale hors d'oeuvres to hearty comfort food (cheese curds, anyone?). If you’re on the hunt for a caterer who gets your vision, understands Midwest hospitality, and creates food your guests will rave about long after the reception, this guide is for you.
Here are three of my favorite Wisconsin wedding catering companies that consistently bring flavor, friendliness, and expertise to the table:
Murry’s on Main Catering
Location: Tomah, WI
Style: Comfort food, classic entrées, and hometown hospitality
If the idea of creamy mashed potatoes, perfectly seasoned green beans, and tender baked chicken makes your heart sing—same. Murry’s on Main offers crowd-pleasing, down-to-earth menus that feel like the best Sunday dinner you’ve ever had, just dressed up for your big day.
What makes them special is their attention to presentation and their warm, personalized service. Their menu options range from homestyle buffets to full-service setups, and their team brings a level of professionalism that helps keep things stress-free. For couples planning a cozy barn wedding or a classic Midwest celebration, Murry’s is a must-consider.
Don't Miss: Their apple crisp and dinner rolls. Trust me.
All Occasions Catering (Bubbs BBQ)
Location: Big Bend, WI
Style: Hearty BBQ and comfort classics with a creative twist
This team is well-known in the southeastern Wisconsin wedding scene—and for good reason. Whether you’re dreaming of smoked brisket, pulled pork, or even upscale plated meals with steak and seafood, All Occasions Catering (aka Bubbs BBQ) brings major flavor to the table.
While their BBQ menu is a standout, they also offer elegant hors d’oeuvres, fresh salad bars, and vegetarian-friendly mains. Their flexibility and wide-ranging menu make them a favorite for couples looking to mix casual food with a formal feel. Bonus: they offer bar service, late-night snack stations, and even rental equipment if needed.
Don't Miss: Their signature sauces and customizable buffet options!
Tall Guy and a Grill
Location: Milwaukee, WI
Style: Farm-to-table, eco-friendly, and event-savvy
If you’re into seasonal menus, locally sourced ingredients, and Pinterest-worthy presentation, Tall Guy and a Grill is calling your name. Based in Milwaukee, this catering company is perfect for couples who want high-end flavor and a modern, fresh approach to food.
Think: summer vegetable medleys, herb-marinated steak, and plated dinners that feel straight out of a magazine. They’re known for beautiful displays, menu flexibility, and an environmentally conscious mindset. If you’re planning a stylish urban wedding, winery celebration, or modern barn party, Tall Guy and a Grill brings both flavor and finesse.
Don't Miss: Their seasonal hors d’oeuvres and locally inspired cocktails!
What to Look for in a Wisconsin Wedding Caterer
When choosing your catering team, you’re hiring more than just chefs—you’re hiring partners who can help make your day run smoothly. Look for a team that:
Communicates clearly and kindly
Offers tastings (and actually listens to your feedback)
Is familiar with your venue’s setup
Has menu flexibility for dietary needs
Understands how timing and service affect your timeline
And if you’re feeling overwhelmed trying to make all the pieces fit together—that’s where a wedding coordinator (hey there!) can step in to help.
Need Help Coordinating Food, Flow, and Fun?
Catering is one of the most important (and biggest!) investments you’ll make in your wedding day. It deserves to be seamless. As a Wisconsin wedding coordinator, I help you build a wedding day timeline that keeps food hot, drinks flowing, and guests happy—without you having to answer a single vendor question that day.
Need help sorting through catering options? Want support building a no-stress wedding day plan? Let’s chat. I’d love to help make your celebration feel as good as it tastes.
Final Thoughts
Great food brings people together—and your wedding day is no exception. Whether you’re planning a relaxed backyard wedding or a high-end soirée, these Wisconsin wedding caterers deliver more than just a meal—they bring ease, energy, and flavor to your big day.
Want to talk timelines, vendor coordination, or how to make sure you actually get a plate at your own wedding? Reach out here, and let’s make wedding magic (and dinner) happen.